-
Jan 11, 2015, 05:52 PM
#1
Are you an A or a B type?
I think it's time for a long term Poll on the MPW forum. So let's see which Flieger pilot watch dials you prefer? I'll use examples from Stowa one of the original five manufactures who made these watches for the German Luftwaffe:
ALS
Laco
Stowa
Wempe
IWC
Type A:
Triangle at the 12 (for orientation) with a dot on each side. Time track on the outer edge of the dial with longer indexes at each 5 minute mark except the 12. Arabic number 1-11 at each 5 minute index except the 12. The hands are generally blued Dauphine style with long stick type second hand that is white tipped from the center post to the end on the side opposite the counter ballance. The hands and the dial markings are lumed for night visibility. Some have only the even number markers lumed (which does not appear to be a standard). This was the earlier Flieger style up to 1941. Case sizes were a large 55mm with very long straps since they were made to be worn on top the the leather jacket sleeves. Most modern are not nearly this large.
Type B:
The Type B was the later style (after 1941)and was casewise similar in size to the Type A. The Type B places the hour and minute tracks separately the dial with the minute track on the outer end and the hour track more in the center of the dial. Arabic numbers are used on both tracks with the triangle at the 12 (for orientation) being placed between the two tracks with a bar under it making it look like an arrow. The minute track has marks for each minute with each 5 minute interval having a double length index mark. Each of these 5 minute indexes is numbered in 5 minute intervals except the 0/60. The inner hour track has a dot on the track circle for each hour interval which are numbered 1-12. The minute and second hand on the Type B are the same as the A, with the hour hand being made shorter to the tip points to the dots on the hour track.
So which do you prefer and why. I'm not allowing a both or neither option so you must choose one.
Last edited by Samanator; Jan 11, 2015 at 05:54 PM.
Cheers,
Michael
Tell everyone you saw it on IWL!
-
Jan 11, 2015, 06:07 PM
#2
-
Post Thanks / Like - 1 Likes
-
Jan 11, 2015, 06:09 PM
#3
I have one or two A's and a B (with small seconds)
-
Jan 11, 2015, 06:38 PM
#4
Random guy
My preference would be the Type A as the simplicity of the dial fits the overall aesthetic of the watch. While I appreciate the added precision in reading the time on the Type B, I wouldn't be timing any bomb drops or refueling rendezvous so find the added text to be more in the nature of clutter.
-
Jan 11, 2015, 06:41 PM
#5
Ich bin ein Ebeler!
+1
Originally Posted by
vinylgreek
My preference would be the Type A as the simplicity of the dial fits the overall aesthetic of the watch. While I appreciate the added precision in reading the time on the Type B, I wouldn't be timing any bomb drops or refueling rendezvous so find the added text to be more in the nature of clutter.
-
Jan 11, 2015, 08:35 PM
#6
I've read though several accounts over the years and the one common claim for the move to the B was that the B was easier to tell the time on quickly. Once I saw a proper B dial I could see that being true. There are quite a few companies that mess up the hand and dial coordination required on the B by having the hands lengths wrong. This may be influencing some to see the B as busy (no pun intended).
Interesting that when GO was building the Senator Navigator Series the no date version used the B dial and the Pano Date version used the A dial set up. The B dial would not accommodate a date function very well and even less a big date. I've also seen some indicate that at the time the ALS Flieger were produced ALS and GO were kind of the same company? This is open for anyone who knows better to dispute.
This is my A dial GO:
Last edited by Samanator; Jan 11, 2015 at 08:37 PM.
Cheers,
Michael
Tell everyone you saw it on IWL!
-
Post Thanks / Like - 1 Likes
-
Jan 11, 2015, 09:09 PM
#7
Watch Geek
+2
I prefer the A for aesthetics. So that's how I'm voting. But for functionality, I'd prefer B ("hands down").
Originally Posted by
vinylgreek
My preference would be the Type A as the simplicity of the dial fits the overall aesthetic of the watch. While I appreciate the added precision in reading the time on the Type B, I wouldn't be timing any bomb drops or refueling rendezvous so find the added text to be more in the nature of clutter.
Regards, T Bone
Even a broken watch shows correct time once or twice a day. I ought to know, I have a few!
-
Jan 11, 2015, 10:57 PM
#8
The counter has stopped
-
Post Thanks / Like - 1 Likes
I-B liked this post
-
Jan 12, 2015, 05:50 AM
#9
-
Post Thanks / Like - 1 Likes
-
Jan 12, 2015, 09:56 AM
#10
dude
I don't have either but since I'm looking more at Type B I went for that. Although I would not rule out a Type A. In fact, I'm expecting I'll have at least one of each sometime in the not too distant future.... then I'll see how I feel....